Should I Ask For A Jury Trial After Being Charged With DWI In Rockland County?
Under the United States Constitution, every defendant has the right to a jury trial. This extends to all criminal charges, including DWIs in Rockland County. The real question is whether a jury trial makes sense for your unique situation. How will the public see your offense? Will they be affected by bias? Could a bench trial lead to more positive outcomes? This is something you might want to discuss with a DWI defense attorney.
The Potential Advantages of a Jury Trial When Facing a DWI
A jury trial can offer numerous advantages for DWI defendants in Rockland County. First, it is important to remember that jurors are average people. Like you, they probably indulge in alcoholic beverages from time to time. They understand how difficult it can be to work full-time jobs and manage family commitments. They may be more understanding of your decision to drink before driving.
A juror may also understand that police officers often make mistakes, and it is possible to drink alcohol without becoming intoxicated. A typical juror might also know that it is possible to drive safely after a few drinks. During a jury trial, the prosecutors must convince all of the jurors that you are guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. This can be challenging, as this represents a high burden of proof. Even if a single juror doubts your guilt, you may be able to avoid consequences.
In contrast, prosecutors only need to convince the judge during a “bench trial.” A bench trial represents the alternative to a jury trial, and it means the judge will play the role of the jury. It may be much easier to convince a single judge of your guilt, especially as judges tend to be more trusting of police testimony. In contrast, a juror might be far more skeptical about what a police officer has to say.
When Should I Choose a Bench Trial?
That said, bench trials could be beneficial in certain situations. A judge may have a better understanding of complex legal concepts, while a juror might struggle to comprehend the intricacies of these details. In theory, a judge is supposed to be impartial and unbiased. This could be advantageous if you face a particularly heinous charge, such as causing the death of a small child in a DWI crash. While the judgment of jurors might be clouded by the stigma that surrounds your allegations, a judge may be clearer-headed. Bench trials are also generally cheaper with lower legal fees.
Can a DWI Defense Attorney in Rockland County Help Me?
A DWI defense attorney in Rockland County may be able to help you decide whether to request a jury trial or a bench trial. The most appropriate choice likely depends on your unique circumstances, and your lawyer can help you assess the pros and cons of both options. Of course, an effective defense strategy is necessary regardless of which option you choose, and this is also something your lawyer can assist with. Contact Phillip J. Murphy, Attorney at Law today to learn more.