Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
Free Consultations Calls answered and returned 24/7
New City Criminal Defense Attorney
Free Consultations Calls answered and returned 24/7
845-639-6600

U.S. Supreme Court Refuses to Hear City Appeal, Effectively Upholding Lower Court’s Decision That Cities Cannot Prosecute the Homeless for Sleeping On the Streets

shutterstock_760012894

In December, the U.S. Supreme Court refused to hear one city’s defense of its policy to prosecute the homeless for sleeping in public, and in doing so, upheld a lower court’s ruling that it violates the constitutional rights of those who sleep in public because there is not enough room in the shelters. As a result, a number of cities – including those in New York and New Jersey – must review their enforcement policies against the homeless for potential violations of protection against cruel and unusual punishment.

The city in this case argued that there was an important, rational basis for the policy, and that was the protection of public health and safety. It also argued that the encampments encouraged gang activity and drug dealing. As a result, various ordinances in the city had essentially defined camping and lodging or sleeping in public to be “disorderly conduct,” as prohibited by the law. Six homeless residents who were prosecuted under the laws sued the city and the 9th Circuit ruled that the policies violated the Eighth Amendment’s prohibition of cruel and unusual punishment if there are more homeless people than available shelter beds. Specifically, the court stated that the government cannot criminalize being indigent, homeless, and sleeping outdoors as though there is a choice in the matter.

Did The Decision Leave Any Wiggle Room to Justify Criminalizing Sleeping Outdoors?

The decision was very specific to the illegality of arresting the homeless for sleeping outdoors when there are no options for sleeping indoors, which could lead to some issues in cities that claim that there are shelters with open spaces and/or those who do not turn anyone away. However, the justices were also quick to point out that, even when it comes to shelters that have a policy of not turning anyone away, there are still a number of limitations, such as the number of days that one person can spend at that particular shelter. The 9th Circuit also handed down a similar ruling in 2006 that indicated that yet another city could not enforce laws against sleeping in public which was not specific about shelter space, indicating that this is a broad decision arguably barring law enforcement from arresting and prosecuting those who must sleep outside.

The Practice Here In New York

Unfortunately, this practice happens all the time here in New York, especially in New York City, where the safest place to sleep is often the subway. This year, Governor Cuomo specifically directed the authorities to “address homelessness in trains and stations.” Reports estimate that there are at least 2,500 police officers just dedicated to policing the subways for this reason. Some have reported that officers bang batons and poke these individuals, using force even though it is after hours when commuters are gone.

If You Have Been Targeted, Contact Our Civil Rights & Criminal Defense Attorneys

If you have been arrested in violation of your civil rights, contact our experienced New York criminal defense attorneys at the office of Phillip J. Murphy today to find out how we can help.

Resource:

theguardian.com/us-news/2019/oct/12/new-york-homeless-subways-police-crackdown

latimes.com/politics/story/2019-12-16/supreme-court-lets-stand-ruling-that-protects-homeless-who-sleep-on-sidewalk

reuters.com/article/us-usa-court-homelessness/u-s-supreme-court-leaves-in-place-ruling-barring-prosecution-of-homeless-idUSKBN1YK1EA

https://www.phillipmurphylawyer.com/trials-for-criminal-defendants-in-new-york-are-about-to-completely-transform-due-to-criminal-justice-reforms/?preview_id=3429&preview_nonce=9c8062f0a7&preview=true&_thumbnail_id=2844

Contact Our Firm

Phillip J. Murphy,
Attorney At Law
Free Consultations Calls Answered and retured 24/7 Phone: (845) 639-6600 Fax: (845) 639-6620

Locations & Directions

10 Esquire Road, Suite 10
New City, New York 10956

We Accept

  • Master Card
  • American Express
  • Discover
  • Visa

Phillip J. Murphy, Attorney At Law is located in New City, New York and serves clients in and around New York, New Jersey & Connecticut. Contact our experienced criminal defense law firm.
- Home - Site Map -

MileMark Media - Practice Growth Solutions

© 2015 - 2020 Phillip J. Murphy, Attorney At Law. All rights reserved.
This law firm website is managed by MileMark Media.
Disclaimer

Contact Form Tab